In Tonicstar Restricted v Allianz Insurance coverage PLC & Ors [2017] EWHC 2753 (Comm) Mr Justice Teare confirmed that where an arbitration clause specifies that the arbitrators should have “working experience of coverage or reinsurance”, it will not be adequate for a proposed arbitrator to have working experience of coverage or reinsurance legislation, or acquiring labored as a experienced advisor to the insurance coverage or reinsurance business the knowledge have to be in the enterprise of insurance plan or reinsurance alone.

In the current situation, the related arbitration clause said that the arbitrators have to have “not a lot less than 10 years’ expertise of insurance policies or reinsurance”. Allianz experienced appointed Mr Alistair Schaff QC as their arbitrator. It was not disputed that Mr Schaff had substantially much more than 10 years’ expertise of insurance and reinsurance regulation. Even so, Tonicstar argued that encounter operating with or on behalf of the insurance policies business was not adequate for the uses of the clause. What was necessary was knowledge operating in the marketplace by itself. It noted that this situation was supported by a former selection of Morison J on this precise issue, Corporation X v Organization Y unreported, 17 July 2000. Allianz argued that this preceding selection was clearly wrong, and should not be followed.

Teare J mentioned that wherever there was a first instance judgment on a related issue, it must normally be followed unless there was a strong explanation not to do so. Though Teare J indicated some sympathy with Allianz’s arguments that encounter in this context ought to include things like encounter gained from operating with or for the insurance policies or reinsurance market, he did not look at that there had been adequately highly effective causes for departing from the conclusion of Morison J. He hence concluded “Mr Schaff, notwithstanding his undoubted knowledge of insurance coverage reinsurance derived from acting as counsel in those people fields, are not able to be appointed as arbitrator in this circumstance.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here